A cozy Christmas shop, a string of local murders, and one very curious shop owner make Fletcher’s Grove anything but quiet. Wonder how you’d fit into this festive mystery? This personality quiz will match you with a character from Mistletoe Murders, whether you’re drawn to Emily Lane’s sleuthing or Sam Wilner’s detective work in a close-knit small town.
About Mistletoe Murders
The 2024 Hallmark mystery series follows Emily Lane, a newcomer who buys a year-round Christmas shop in Fletcher’s Grove, New York. When murders unsettle the town, Emily puts her sleuthing skills to work, despite Detective Sam Wilner’s objections. Their growing connection adds a layer of romantic tension, while Emily’s mysterious past leaves questions about what brought her to town—and what she’s really after. Festive decorations, small-town life, and murder investigations share the scene.
Mistletoe Murders Character Profiles
Emily Lane
Emily Lane runs a year-round Christmas shop in Fletcher’s Grove, where her cheerful, welcoming manner makes her seem perfectly at home among the town’s festive traditions. Beneath that sunny exterior is a sharp, highly observant mind and an unusual talent for investigation. Emily often gets involved in local mysteries despite Detective Sam Wilner’s reservations. Independent and guarded, she is still working through a complicated past while trying to build a life where she can feel safe and truly belong.
Sam Wilner
Detective Sam Wilner is a levelheaded, methodical member of the Fletcher’s Grove Police Department who values evidence and proper procedure. His investigations are complicated by Emily Lane’s habit of pursuing clues on her own, though his frustration with her boundary-crossing is tempered by patience and respect. Away from the job, Sam is a devoted single father whose teenage daughter, Violet, is central to his life. He approaches both family and relationships with care, preferring trust and honesty to easy assumptions.
Violet Wilner
Violet Wilner is Sam’s teenage daughter, a perceptive young person with a sharp eye for the dynamics around her. As her father’s connection with Emily develops, Violet finds herself between them, helping bring their differing perspectives into view. She is supportive without losing her independence, and she is navigating her own place within a family dynamic that is changing. Violet’s intuition often allows her to notice what adults overlook, while her own needs and boundaries remain important to her.
Brooke Carmichael
Brooke Carmichael is part of the lively social fabric of Fletcher’s Grove, where her eccentric streak and interest in local happenings add a dose of small-town color. She shares a gossipy, spirited quality with fellow resident June Hubble, but Brooke’s loyalty to her community is just as defining. Amid the town’s holiday cheer and unsettling mysteries, she helps give Fletcher’s Grove its distinctive personality, balancing comic energy with the close ties that bind its residents.
Sue Shin
Sue Shin is a pragmatic, no-nonsense presence in Fletcher’s Grove, offering a grounded counterpoint to the town’s abundant festive enthusiasm. Her direct manner and dry perspective distinguish her from the more theatrical or excitable residents. Rather than joining every burst of local excitement, Sue tends to keep her attention on what is practical and real. In a community balancing holiday cheer with a run of mysteries, her steady outlook provides a welcome contrast to the surrounding bustle.
