Skip to content

Which ‘Good Witch’ Character Are You?

So, welcome to this “Good Witch: Which Character Are You?” thing. Not a test, not homework—just a little stroll into Middleton, where the air smells like cinnamon candles and someone’s always got a secret in their back pocket. You might end up being Cassie, you might be Martha, hell, maybe you’re Sam with that doctorly eyebrow raise. Don’t overthink it. Just roll with it, see who you really vibe with.

Welcome to Quiz: Which 'Good Witch' Character Are You

About “Good Witch” in a few words:

Good Witch. Yeah, that Hallmark gem that lived from 2015 to 2021. It’s not witches with wands and fireballs, no, it’s softer. Cassie Nightingale, who’s less “abra-cadabra” and more “I know what’s in your heart before you say it.” She’s got a town full of oddballs—grouchy mayors, skeptical doctors, cousins with sharp tongues, neighbors falling in love over pie. It’s sweet. It’s cozy. A little magic sprinkled like powdered sugar on top of your everyday drama.

Meet the characters from Good Witch

Cassie Nightingale

Oh man, Cassie is like the heart and soul of Good Witch, right? She’s this super warm and caring witch who just radiates positivity and magic. Seriously, her intuition is on another level; it’s like she knows what you’re thinking before you do! And the way she brings the community together through her enchanting little potions and baked goodies — you can’t help but love her! Plus, she has this mysterious vibe, like, where did she even come from? It’s just so intriguing!

Mayor Martha Tinsdale

Okay, let’s talk about Mayor Martha! She’s the quintessential small-town mayor, but with a twist of sass that keeps things interesting! Like, one minute she’s all about the town’s traditions, and the next she’s throwing down some serious shade! Love how she’s got this big personality and isn’t afraid to speak her mind. But deep down, she really cares about the community and wants what’s best for everyone, which is kinda sweet, you know? And I totally can’t get enough of her obsession with the town’s image — it’s like she’s the ultimate control freak but in the best way!

Dr. Sam Radford

Oh boy, Dr. Sam is such a gem! He’s the town’s doctor and has that perfect blend of rugged charm and genuine kindness. Like, he’s always there to lend a helping hand, but he’s also got this brooding side that makes you wonder what’s going on in his head! And his chemistry with Cassie? UGH, it’s just so cute! But then there are moments where he can be a bit oblivious, like, come on, Sam, get it together! But hey, that just makes him feel more human, right?

Stephanie Borden

Can we just take a second to appreciate Stephanie? She’s got that fierce energy and ambition that just lights up the screen! Seriously, she’s driven and passionate about her career, and it’s inspiring to watch her chase her dreams. But then, every now and then, she shows this vulnerable side that makes you root for her even more! And don’t get me started on her friendship with Cassie; it’s like they’re the ultimate power duo! She can be a little competitive, but in the most lovable way!

Abigail Pershing

OMG, Abigail is such a fun character! She’s got this quirky mix of ambition and mischief that makes her super relatable! Sometimes she can be a bit self-serving, but you know she has a good heart deep down. And her journey throughout the show? Epic! Watching her evolve from a bit of a schemer into someone who genuinely cares about the town is just so satisfying! Plus, her little one-liners are pure gold! Like, she’s the kind of friend who’ll definitely tell you the truth, no matter how painful it might be — and we love her for it!